The Tax Brief real effective rates for 111+ countries β€” bi-weekly, free.
HEAD-TO-HEAD TAX COMPARISON Β· 2026

COUNTRY A New York VS COUNTRY B New Jersey

Side-by-side analysis of income tax, effective rates, and take-home pay for New York and New Jersey in 2026.

OVERVIEW
New York and New Jersey are both high-tax states, but the comparison depends heavily on whether you live in NYC. New York State: 3.9-10.9% progressive. NYC residents add 3.078-3.876% city tax, reaching a combined 14.8% only on income above $25 million. New Jersey: 1.4-10.75% state income tax and the highest effective property tax rate in the nation (1.88%, tied with Illinois at that rounding; Tax Foundation), compared with 0.56%-0.75% in the NYC counties. NYC figures here are NY State plus New York City resident income tax after the NYC school tax credit. For NYC residents at $100,000: NY total ~$8,036, NJ ~$4,180. NJ saves $3,856 in income tax BUT property taxes can eliminate savings. For NY State (outside NYC) at $100,000: NY ~$4,861, NJ ~$4,180. NJ still wins by $681, though the gap is much narrower than for NYC residents. The calculus: Renters/apartment dwellers often save in NJ. Homeowners may lose savings to NJ property taxes. Many work in NYC and live in NJ to balance taxes with quality of life. Choose NYC if: you want city lifestyle, don't mind renting, or work-from-home isn't an option. Choose NJ if: you want more space, prefer suburbs, and can handle property taxes.
Section 01

The Big Picture

Top-line rates and effective take-home for a typical earner β€” including income tax, social contributions, and applicable surcharges.

πŸ—½
COUNTRY A
New York
TAX RATE
3.9-10.9%
Progressive + NYC

3.9-10.9% state + 3.078-3.876% NYC for city residents

🏠
COUNTRY B
New Jersey
TAX RATE
1.4-10.75%
Progressive

1.4-10.75% progressive, high property taxes

TYPICAL ANNUAL DIFFERENCE
Moving from New York β†’ New Jersey at $100,000 (vs NYC)
$3,856

That's $321/month back in your pocket

Section 02

Tax Savings by Income Level

Net take-home after all income tax, social contributions, and surcharges β€” for a single employee with no dependents.

GROSS INCOME
πŸ—½ NY TAX
🏠 NJ TAX
SAVINGS
10-YEAR
$75,000
$5,716 (7.6% - NYC)
$2,596 (3.5%)
NJ saves $3,120
$31,200
$100,000
$8,036 (8.0% - NYC)
$4,180 (4.2%)
NJ saves $3,856
$38,560
$150,000
$13,290 (8.9% - NYC)
$7,365 (4.9%)
NJ saves $5,925
$59,250
$250,000
$24,594 (9.8% - NYC)
$13,735 (5.5%)
NJ saves $10,859
$108,590
πŸ’‘

CountryTaxCalc.com is reader-supported. When you use our partner links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. This helps us provide free tax calculators and comparison tools.Learn more about our affiliate partnerships

Talk to a Real CPA

Taxhub

β˜… 4.8verified reviews  Β·  3,758 reviews

Moving from New York to New Jersey? Multi-state returns are trickyβ€”partial-year residency, different deadlines, avoiding double taxation. Get matched with a CPA who specializes in state moves. Virtual meetings, fixed pricing.

⚠ Not for simple single-state returns. Free filing is fine for straightforward W-2 situations.

Get Matched With a CPA β†’
πŸ—½

New York Pros & Cons

+ PROS
  • NYC lifestyle: World-class culture, dining, entertainment, career opportunities
  • No car needed: Excellent public transit eliminates car costs
  • Lower property taxes: NYC property taxes much lower than NJ
  • Career opportunities: More industries and higher salaries in many fields
  • NY State (outside NYC): Income tax is now close to New Jersey's, though slightly higher at most income levels shown
βˆ’ CONS
  • NYC tax: Additional 3.078-3.876% city tax for Manhattan/Brooklyn/etc residents
  • High cost of living: NYC housing among most expensive in US
  • Combined rate: Reaches about 14.8% only on income above $25 million
  • Commuter tax complexity: NJ residents working in NYC face multi-state filing
🏠

New Jersey Pros & Cons

+ PROS
  • Lower income tax: 1.4-10.75% vs NY State's 3.9-10.9% (up to 14.8% with NYC)
  • More space: Larger homes, yards, suburban lifestyle
  • Good schools: Many excellent public school districts
  • NYC access: PATH, NJ Transit make commuting viable
  • No sales tax on clothing: Small but meaningful savings
βˆ’ CONS
  • Highest effective property tax rate in the US (1.88%, tied with Illinois at that rounding), versus 0.56%-0.75% in the NYC counties
  • Car required: Most of NJ needs a car, adds $5-10K/year in costs
  • Commute times: 1-2 hours each way to NYC is common
  • Fewer walkable areas: Less urban lifestyle options
FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

How much will I save living in NJ vs NYC?

At $100K income: NJ income tax ~$4,180 vs NYC total ~$8,036 (after the NYC school tax credit). NJ saves ~$3,856 in income tax. BUT: effective property tax rates are far higher in NJ (statewide 1.88%; 1.56%-2.10% in Hudson, Bergen and Essex counties) than in the NYC counties (0.56%-0.75%), per Tax Foundation. If you're a homeowner, property taxes can eliminate or exceed income tax savings. Renters benefit more from NJ.

What about living in NY State but outside NYC?

Outside NYC, you pay only state tax (3.9-10.9%), no city tax. At $100K: ~$4,861. This is actually HIGHER than NJ's ~$4,180 β€” New Jersey is now cheaper even compared to non-NYC New York, by about $681 at $100K. Westchester, Long Island, Hudson Valley residents pay somewhat more income tax than NJ residents, though the gap is small and NJ's crushing property taxes can still make non-NYC New York the better overall choice for homeowners.

Do NJ residents working in NYC pay NY taxes?

Yes, you pay NY State income tax on NY-sourced income but NOT NYC tax (non-residents exempt). You get a credit on your NJ return for taxes paid to NY. Effectively, you pay the higher of the two rates. This makes the NJ benefit smaller for NYC workers than pure NJ workers.

Which is better for high earners ($250K+)?

NJ income tax savings become substantial: ~$10,859/year at $250K. Even with high NJ property taxes, high earners often come out ahead in NJ IF they're willing to commute. The math favors NJ more as income rises because income tax savings outpace property tax costs.

What about remote workers?

Not as simple as it looks. If you live in NJ and work remotely for a New York employer, NY's convenience-of-the-employer test can still treat your pay for days worked at home as New York-source income unless you work out of state because the employer requires it (NY Tax Department memo TSB-M-06(5)I, 20 NYCRR 132.18(a)). You would pay NY State tax on that income (not NYC tax, since you are a nonresident) and claim a credit on your NJ return. If your employer is not based in New York, only days physically worked in New York are New York-source. Check your own facts with a tax professional.