The Tax Brief real effective rates for 111+ countries — bi-weekly, free.
HEAD-TO-HEAD TAX COMPARISON · 2026

COUNTRY A New Jersey VS COUNTRY B New York

Side-by-side analysis of income tax, effective rates, and take-home pay for New Jersey and New York in 2026.

Daniel · CountryTaxCalc Updated May 2026 Tax Comparison 2026
Calculate your take-home → See all comparisons →
OVERVIEW
New Jersey has an average property tax rate tied for the highest in the United States (with Illinois) at 1.88% — above New York's 1.30%. On a $600,000 home, New Jersey homeowners pay approximately $3,480 more per year than New York counterparts. However, New Jersey's income tax peaks at 10.75% (on income above $1M) versus New York's 10.9% state rate — plus NYC adds up to 3.876% for city residents. For high earners living in New York City, moving to New Jersey can actually reduce total taxes despite higher property bills. This is the classic NJ-NY commuter trade-off — pay more in property, save on income taxes if you avoid NYC.
Section 01

The Big Picture

Top-line rates and effective take-home for a typical earner — including income tax, social contributions, and applicable surcharges.

🏙️
COUNTRY A
New Jersey
TAX RATE
1.88%
Avg Effective Rate

Property tax rate tied for highest in the US (with Illinois); average annual bill over $9,000

🗽
COUNTRY B
New York
TAX RATE
1.30%
Avg Effective Rate

High but below NJ; NYC residents also face city income tax; upstate rates vary widely

TYPICAL ANNUAL DIFFERENCE
Moving from New York → New Jersey at $600,000 home
$3,480

New York saves on property tax

Section 02

Tax Savings by Income Level

Net take-home after all income tax, social contributions, and surcharges — for a single employee with no dependents.

GROSS INCOME
🏙️ NJ TAX
🗽 NY TAX
SAVINGS
10-YEAR
$400,000 home
$7,520
$5,200
$2,320
$23,200
$600,000 home
$11,280
$7,800
$3,480
$34,800
$800,000 home
$15,040
$10,400
$4,640
$46,400
$1,000,000 home
$18,800
$13,000
$5,800
$58,000
$1,500,000 home
$28,200
$19,500
$8,700
$87,000
$2,000,000 home
$37,600
$26,000
$11,600
$116,000
💡

CountryTaxCalc.com is reader-supported. When you use our partner links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. This helps us provide free tax calculators and comparison tools. Learn more about our affiliate partnerships

Talk to a Real CPA

Taxhub

★ 4.8 verified reviews  ·  3,758 reviews

Moving between New Jersey and New York? NYC city tax domicile rules, NJ commuter tax treatment, partial-year residency filings, and establishing domicile in the correct state are all complex. Get matched with a CPA who specialises in NY/NJ state moves.

⚠ Not for simple single-state returns. Free filing is fine for straightforward W-2 situations.

Get Matched With a CPA →

Interested in reaching this audience? Advertise on CountryTaxCalc →

🏙️

New Jersey Pros & Cons

+ PROS
  • No NYC city income tax (saves 3.876% on earned income for commuters)
  • Slightly lower top state income tax rate than NY for most income levels
  • More space and suburban quality of life for the money
  • ANCHOR rebate program offsets property tax for lower-income homeowners
− CONS
  • Property tax rate tied for highest in the United States (with Illinois)
  • Average NJ tax bill over $9,000/year statewide
  • Bergen, Essex, Morris, Union counties often exceed $15,000–$25,000/year
  • High combined state + property tax burden overall
🗽

New York Pros & Cons

+ PROS
  • Lower property tax rate (31% lower than NJ average)
  • NYC apartments and condos assessed at a fraction of market value
  • STAR program reduces school taxes for homeowners
  • Strong transit network reduces car ownership costs
− CONS
  • NYC residents pay additional city income tax (up to 3.876%)
  • NY state income tax up to 10.9% (matching or exceeding NJ at most income levels)
  • NYC co-op/condo maintenance fees often include hidden property taxes
  • Combined NY state + NYC income tax burden among the highest in the US
FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Is New Jersey or New York more expensive for taxes overall?

It depends on where in New York. For NYC residents: New York City's combined state + city income tax (up to 14.776% combined at top incomes) significantly exceeds New Jersey's rates. A high earner in Manhattan pays substantially more in income taxes than the same earner in suburban NJ — even accounting for NJ's higher property taxes. For upstate New York residents (outside NYC): New York and New Jersey income tax rates are broadly similar, but NJ's property tax is substantially higher. Most financial analyses conclude that for high-income NYC area earners, New Jersey offers better overall value.

Why is New Jersey's property tax tied for the highest in the US?

New Jersey's high property taxes reflect its funding structure: local governments and school districts rely heavily on property tax revenue. Factors include: one of the highest education spending levels per pupil in the US; a fragmented municipal system (over 560 municipalities); limited state aid relative to local needs; high median home values that translate headline rates into large dollar bills; and political resistance to state income tax increases (NJ's income tax is relatively low for most earners). The result is a property tax burden that ties Illinois for the highest average of any US state.

What is New Jersey's ANCHOR program?

New Jersey's ANCHOR (Affordable New Jersey Communities for Homeowners and Renters) program provides property tax relief: homeowners earning up to $150,000 receive $1,500; homeowners earning $150,001–$250,000 receive $1,000; renters receive $450 (income limits apply). These rebates directly offset NJ's high property tax bills. A homeowner paying $11,800/year in NJ property tax who qualifies for the $1,500 ANCHOR benefit effectively pays $10,300 net — still more than New York for equivalent homes, but the gap narrows.

How do New Jersey and New York compare for retirees on property tax?

Both states offer senior property tax relief. New Jersey: the Senior Freeze (Property Tax Reimbursement) reimburses eligible seniors (65+, income below ~$150,000) for the increase in property taxes from their base year — protecting against rate increases. Additionally, NJ's Homestead Benefit reduces assessed value. New York: the Enhanced STAR exemption provides an additional $70,700 deduction for seniors 65+ with income below $98,700. Given NJ's much higher base rates, NY still typically costs less in absolute dollar property tax — but NJ's income tax is lower for retirement income in some brackets.
From the brief
NL27%new 2027 rate, down from 30%
DK65.4kkr/mo threshold, cut from 78k
MT1940snon-dom regime unchanged since
The Tax Brief · Subscribe free

More like this, every two weeks.

Verified rates, real after-tax figures, plain English. Free.

Bi-weekly. No spam. Unsubscribe in one click.