The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA, P.L. 119-21) created a federal income tax deduction of up to $12,500 (single) or $25,000 (married filing jointly) on the FLSA overtime premium (the pay above the regular rate) for tax years 2025–2028. For workers in Texas or Florida, that is a straightforward saving — no state income tax to worry about at all. For workers in New York State, the picture is considerably worse.
New York has not conformed to the federal OBBBA overtime deduction. New York State uses federal adjusted gross income (AGI) as the starting point for the NY return (Form IT-201). The OBBBA overtime deduction is claimed on federal Schedule 1-A and reduces taxable income, not AGI, so it never enters New York's starting point — and the 2025 IT-201 instructions contain no separate New York overtime deduction. The federal deduction you claimed on your 1040 therefore brings no state benefit.
That means New York workers pay NY state income tax — at rates ranging up to 10.9%, with most earners in the 5.4%–5.9% range — on the full amount of their overtime income, as if the OBBBA deduction never existed. And for people who live in New York City, there is a third layer: NYC's own resident income tax of 3.078%–3.876%, which also applies to all overtime earnings with no exemption.
The combined federal benefit plus full state and city tax exposure makes New York one of the most costly states for overtime earners in 2026. A single NYC resident earning $65,000 in base pay plus $18,000 in overtime pays roughly $21,127 in combined federal income tax, FICA, state, and city taxes — compared to approximately $14,460 for an identical worker in Texas. That is a $6,667 annual gap attributable entirely to New York and New York City taxes on income the federal government chose to partially shelter.
Despite New York State's non-conformity, NY workers are not entirely without benefit from the OBBBA. The federal deduction still reduces their federal income tax liability — and that saving is real.
The OBBBA created a deduction claimed on Schedule 1-A that reduces your federal taxable income (it does not reduce AGI) and is available whether or not you itemise. For a New York single filer earning $83,000 in total income ($65,000 base + $18,000 overtime pay), the OBBBA applies as follows on the federal return (assuming the overtime is paid at time-and-a-half, so the premium is one third of the overtime pay):
If the worker's total overtime premium reaches $12,500 or more in the year, the federal saving maxes out at $12,500 × 22% = $2,750 (22% bracket) or $12,500 × 24% = $3,000 (24% bracket).
Only the premium component of FLSA overtime pay qualifies — that is, the extra 0.5× pay for hours beyond 40 per week. The regular-rate component of overtime hours (the base 1.0×) is ordinary wage income. Example: at $25/hour, 10 hours of overtime generates $375 in total overtime pay — but only $125 (0.5 × $25 × 10) qualifies as the premium for OBBBA purposes.
The federal deduction is reduced by $100 for each $1,000 of modified AGI above $150,000 (single) or $300,000 (married filing jointly), and is gone at $275,000 (single) / $550,000 (joint) for a full-cap deduction. Most NY hourly overtime workers — nurses, construction workers, transit employees, manufacturing workers — fall well below these thresholds. The federal deduction is fully available at typical NY overtime income levels. Higher-income NY workers who approach these thresholds face both the phase-out of the federal benefit and the full weight of NY state and NYC city taxes with no offset.
Source: IRS — OBBBA Tax Deductions for Working Americans and Seniors
New York State uses federal AGI as the starting point for its own tax calculation, and it has no state deduction that mirrors the federal OBBBA overtime deduction.
New York begins its calculation with federal AGI (IT-201 line 19). The OBBBA overtime deduction is claimed on federal Schedule 1-A below AGI, so your federal AGI is the same whether or not you claim it. Nothing has to be added back — the deduction simply never enters the New York calculation.
In practical terms: if your federal AGI is $83,000 and you claim a $12,500 OBBBA deduction, your federal taxable income falls by $12,500, but your NY IT-201 starting point stays at $83,000.
New York has not enacted any parallel state-level overtime deduction or exemption to replace the federal benefit. The 2025 IT-201 instructions list no New York deduction or subtraction for overtime premium pay. Every dollar of overtime earned by a New York resident is fully subject to NY state income tax at the worker's applicable marginal rate.
For a worker in the 5.4%–5.9% NY state brackets — which cover roughly $13,900 to $215,400 of NY taxable income for single filers — each dollar of overtime earnings generates approximately:
At the top NY bracket (10.9%, applicable above $25 million of taxable income), the combined NY + NYC marginal rate on overtime approaches 14.8% — on top of the federal rate and FICA.
Source: New York Department of Taxation and Finance (tax.ny.gov)
New York City imposes its own resident income tax on all income earned by city residents — one of only a handful of US cities with a broad-based individual income tax. This is not withheld as a flat fee but calculated as a percentage of income, with its own rate schedule. It applies fully to overtime earnings with no exemption or deduction for OBBBA purposes.
| NYC Taxable Income (Single) | NYC Rate |
|---|---|
| Up to $12,000 | 3.078% |
| $12,001 – $25,000 | 3.762% |
| $25,001 – $50,000 | 3.819% |
| Above $50,000 | 3.876% |
For a single NYC resident with $75,000 of NY taxable income (after standard deduction), the NYC tax is $1,813 + 3.876% × ($75,000 − $50,000) = $2,782 per year (an average rate of about 3.7%).
NYC income tax applies to NYC residents — people domiciled in the five boroughs (Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island). Commuters who work in NYC but live in New Jersey, Connecticut, or other NY suburbs do not pay NYC resident income tax (NYC's nonresident commuter earnings tax was repealed effective July 1, 1999). Staten Island and outer-borough residents who often work construction, healthcare, or transit jobs in the city pay the full NYC tax on all their income including overtime.
Yonkers imposes a resident income tax surcharge of 16.75% of NY state tax liability (roughly 0.9%–1.15% of income at the 5.4%–6.85% state rates) and a non-resident earnings tax of 0.5%. Other NY municipalities have varying local taxes. The NYC rate is the highest and most significant, but NY workers outside the city should check their municipality's local tax rules.
For an NYC resident, $18,000 of overtime earnings at the 3.876% NYC rate generates approximately $698 in NYC city income tax on just the overtime portion. Over a full year of consistent overtime, this adds up. Combined with the NY state tax and the lost OBBBA federal benefit, NYC residents face the full combined burden with no state or city offset.
Source: New York Department of Taxation and Finance (tax.ny.gov)
The following example illustrates the full tax stack for a single NY state resident and NYC resident earning $65,000 in base salary and $18,000 in overtime (assuming $6,000 of that is the qualifying overtime premium). It is compared against an identical worker in Texas who pays no state income tax.
The NYC resident pays approximately $6,667 more per year in total taxes than the identical Texas worker on the same $83,000 of earnings. This gap is driven entirely by NY state and NYC city taxes — both of which apply in full to all overtime income with no conformity to the federal OBBBA deduction.
Note: These figures are illustrative estimates based on 2026 rate schedules. Individual results vary based on actual deductions, credits, filing status, and withholding. Use our calculator for a personalised estimate.
Regardless of the federal OBBBA deduction and regardless of NY's non-conformity, FICA taxes apply to all overtime earnings for every US worker — NY residents and Texas residents alike.
For the worker earning $83,000 total: $83,000 × 7.65% = approximately $6,350 in FICA. This is identical for the NY worker and the Texas worker — FICA is a federal payroll tax and is not affected by state income tax policy or by whether the OBBBA deduction is claimed.
The OBBBA overtime deduction is an income tax deduction — it reduces the income on which federal and state income tax is calculated. It does not reduce the wages that FICA applies to. FICA is calculated on gross wages before any income tax deductions. This is a key distinction: the OBBBA saves income tax, not payroll tax. A worker at the $12,500 OBBBA cap saves up to $3,000 in income tax — but continues to owe FICA on all their earnings including the $12,500 of overtime premium.
NY workers, like all US workers, also do not have a NY state equivalent of FICA. New York does not impose a separate state payroll tax on employees for income tax purposes (though employers pay NY State Unemployment Insurance and employees pay a small SDI/PFL contribution, these are benefit-linked and not income taxes).
Source: IRS Topic No. 751 — Social Security and Medicare Withholding Rates
New York State follows the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) overtime framework but adds its own minimum wage requirements that affect how overtime rates are calculated for lower-wage NY workers.
Like most states (but unlike California), New York applies overtime after 40 hours in a workweek — not after 8 hours in a single day. Under NY Labor Law §651 and the FLSA, non-exempt employees must receive at least 1.5 times their regular rate of pay for all hours worked beyond 40 in a workweek.
New York sets its own minimum wage above the federal $7.25/hour floor. Under NY Labor Law §652, the 2026 minimum wages are:
These minimum wages directly affect the overtime rate calculation. A minimum-wage worker in NYC earning $17/hour must receive at least $25.50/hour (1.5 × $17) for all overtime hours — higher than in most US states. This means even low-wage NY workers earn a meaningful overtime premium, all of which is subject to full NY state and NYC city income tax.
Because NY follows the FLSA weekly threshold, the qualifying OBBBA premium for NY workers is calculated the same way as in Texas and other FLSA-only states:
NY workers claim the same federal deduction as Texas workers — the difference is that NY gives no state deduction for it.
Source: NY Department of Labor — Minimum Wage (labor.ny.gov)
Since New York does not conform to the OBBBA, NY overtime workers cannot reduce their state tax bill through the federal deduction mechanism. But several planning strategies can still lower the overall tax on overtime earnings.
Contributing to a traditional 401(k) or traditional IRA reduces both federal AGI and NY taxable income, because New York generally follows federal treatment of retirement contributions. This is the single most powerful tool for NY overtime workers:
For a NYC resident earning $83,000 and maxing a 401(k) at $24,500: NY taxable income drops from ~$75,000 to ~$50,500. At New York's 5.4% marginal rate for that income range (2026 schedule: 5.4% on taxable income from $13,900 to $80,650), that saves approximately $1,323 in NY state tax, and NYC's 3.819%–3.876% rates on that $24,500 slice of income save approximately $936 in NYC city tax — in addition to the federal tax saving.
Health Savings Account contributions are another above-the-line federal deduction — and NY conforms to HSA treatment. Single filers can contribute up to $4,400 in 2026 (family: $8,750). HSA contributions reduce both federal and NY taxable income, providing a combined federal + state + city tax saving for NYC residents.
Employer-sponsored pre-tax FSA contributions reduce W-2 wages — they are excluded from both federal and NY taxable income. Dependent care FSA limits ($7,500/household in 2026) are particularly valuable for NYC resident overtime workers with childcare costs.
Workers with control over when they take overtime may benefit from timing income to avoid crossing into higher NY brackets. This is more relevant for NY single filers near the $80,650 or $215,400 taxable-income bracket thresholds (where NY rates step up). However, declining overtime to manage taxes is generally a poor trade-off — the after-tax income from overtime is almost always positive even in NY's highest brackets.
NYC's city income tax applies only to NYC residents. Workers who live in New Jersey, Connecticut, Long Island, or Westchester and commute into the city pay no NYC resident income tax — saving 3.8%+ on all income including overtime. The trade-off is commuting cost and time. For high-OT workers consistently earning $15,000–$25,000 in overtime annually, the $570–$970+ per year NYC tax saving on just the overtime portion alone may not justify relocation, but the total NYC tax saving on full income (potentially $2,500–$4,000/year) is worth calculating.
Planning note: These are general strategies for illustration only. Tax outcomes depend on your full financial picture. Consult a qualified NY tax professional for personalised advice.
CountryTaxCalc.com is reader-supported. When you use our partner links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. This helps us provide free tax calculators and comparison tools.Learn more about our affiliate partnerships
★ 4.8verified reviews · 3,758 reviews
Moving between states means a complex multi-state tax return. Taxhub matches you with a real CPA via video call — average cost $325. Rated 4.8★ by 3,700+ clients.
⚠ Not for simple single-state returns. Free filing is fine for straightforward W-2 situations.
Get Matched With a CPA →Interested in reaching this audience? Advertise on CountryTaxCalc →