Indiana vs Michigan Taxes: Indiana Saves $900/Year at State Level (2026)

OVERVIEW

Indiana’s 3.15% flat state rate is lower than Michigan’s 4.05%, saving $900/year on $100,000 income at the state level. However, Indiana’s county income taxes (averaging 1.5%, ranging up to 3.38%) can substantially narrow or eliminate the gap for many Indiana residents. Detroit residents face Michig…

Section 01

The Big Picture

Top-line rates and effective take-home for a typical earner — including income tax, social contributions, and applicable surcharges.

🏀

COUNTRY A

Indiana

TAX RATE

3.15%

Flat Rate

3.15% flat state rate (reducing to 2.9% by 2027) plus county income taxes

🚗

COUNTRY B

Michigan

TAX RATE

4.05%

Flat Rate

4.05% flat state rate; Detroit residents pay additional 2.4% city income tax

Section 02

Tax Savings by Income Level

Net take-home after all income tax, social contributions, and surcharges — for a single employee with no dependents.

GROSS INCOME

🏀 IN TAX

🚗 MI TAX

SAVINGS

10-YEAR

$50,000

$1,575

$2,025

$450

$4,500

$75,000

$2,363

$3,038

$675

$6,750

$100,000

$3,150

$4,050

$900

$9,000

$150,000

$4,725

$6,075

$1,350

$13,500

$250,000

$7,875

$10,125

$2,250

$22,500

$500,000

$15,750

$20,250

$4,500

$45,000

💡

CountryTaxCalc.com is reader-supported. When you use our partner links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. This helps us provide free tax calculators and comparison tools. Learn more about our affiliate partnerships

Talk to a Real CPA

TaxHub

★ 4.8 verified reviews · 3,758 reviews

Moving between states? Multi-state returns, partial-year residency, and domicile changes are complex. TaxHub connects you with licensed CPAs who specialise in state tax moves.

⚠ Not for simple single-state returns. Free filing is fine for straightforward W-2 situations.

Talk to a CPA About Your State Move →

Interested in reaching this audience? Advertise on CountryTaxCalc →

🏀

Indiana Pros & Cons

+ PROS

Lower state income tax rate: 3.15% vs Michigan’s 4.05% saves $900/year on $100k at the state level
Property tax cap: Indiana caps residential property tax at 1% of assessed value by constitutional amendment
Rate reduction underway: Indiana’s rate is scheduled to fall to 2.9% by 2027, widening the gap further
No city income tax: unlike Detroit (2.4% city tax), Indiana cities do not impose separate income taxes

− CONS

County income taxes: Indiana counties charge 0.5–3.38% on top of the state rate, averaging ~1.5%, which can erase the state-level savings vs Michigan
Indianapolis metro smaller than Detroit: fewer Fortune 500 HQs and a narrower corporate base
Limited public transit: Indiana ranks poorly for transit investment and urban connectivity
Higher sales tax than Michigan: Indiana 7% vs Michigan 6% costs an extra $100/year on $10k of spending

🚗

Michigan Pros & Cons

+ PROS

No county income taxes for most residents: Michigan’s 4.05% is the full rate outside Detroit
Strong manufacturing and tech sector: Michigan hosts major automakers and a growing EV supply chain
Lower sales tax: Michigan 6% vs Indiana 7% saves $100/year on $10k of taxable purchases
Three-tier retirement tax: Michigan residents born before 1946 enjoy substantial pension and retirement income exemptions

− CONS

Higher flat rate: Michigan 4.05% vs Indiana 3.15% costs $900 more at $100k at the state level alone
Detroit city income tax: Detroit residents pay an additional 2.4% city tax on top of Michigan’s state rate
Higher property tax: Michigan 1.32% vs Indiana 1% cap costs $1,280 more/year on a $400k home
Rust Belt challenges: Detroit and Flint have faced long-term population decline, crime, and infrastructure issues

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Indiana really save $900 vs Michigan on taxes?

At the state rate level, yes — Indiana’s 3.15% vs Michigan’s 4.05% saves $900/year on $100,000 income. However, Indiana also charges county income taxes (averaging ~1.5%), which most Michigan residents outside Detroit do not face. An Indiana resident in Marion County (1.02%) pays about $1,020 in county tax, bringing their total to $4,170 vs Michigan’s $4,050. The true winner depends on which Indiana county you live in. In low-county-tax areas, Indiana clearly wins; in high-county-tax areas, Michigan may be cheaper.

How much extra tax do Detroit residents pay compared to the rest of Michigan?

Detroit residents pay a 2.4% city income tax on top of Michigan’s 4.05% state rate, for a combined 6.45% on earned income. On $100,000, that’s $6,450 in state+city income tax — compared to $3,150 in Indiana. Detroit residents would save $3,300/year by moving to Indiana (before county taxes). Non-Detroit Michigan residents pay only the 4.05% state rate, which is much more competitive.

What is Indiana’s property tax cap and how does it work?

Indiana’s property tax caps are enshrined in its state constitution. Residential properties are capped at 1% of gross assessed value, rental properties at 2%, and commercial/agricultural at 3%. This means on a $400,000 home, Indiana homeowners pay a maximum of $4,000/year in property taxes, regardless of the local rate. Michigan’s average property tax of 1.32% on a $400k home costs $5,280/year — $1,280 more. Indiana’s cap provides significant and predictable protection for homeowners.

Is Indiana’s income tax going down further?

Yes. Indiana passed legislation to reduce its flat state income tax rate in steps. The rate was 3.23% until 2023, cut to 3.15% in 2024, and is scheduled to reach 2.9% by 2027 under current law. This phased reduction makes Indiana’s income tax trajectory one of the most favourable in the Midwest. By 2027, Indiana vs Michigan will be a 2.9% vs 4.05% comparison — a $1,150/year difference on $100,000 income at the state level.

🏀 COUNTRY A Indiana VS 🚗 COUNTRY B Michigan